In the age-old argument about nature versus nurture, genetics versus environment, I am a fervent supporter of the environment theory. Indeed, I am positively desperate for it to be true.
My reasons are personal and concern an incident involving an ancestor many years ago.
If the geneticists are right, I may have inherited certain characteristics I would much rather have avoided.
But I'm getting ahead of myself.
Are we born cheerful, gloomy, generous or argumentative? Or are we made that way by our parents, our education and the society in which we live?
For much of the twentieth century, environmental explanations were influential. Unfortunately, studies of twins suggest that genes account for around 40 per cent of the variation in personality across a population. That doesn't mean 40 per cent of your personality comes from your genes, but it does mean heredity matters rather more than I would wish. Which brings me to Black Jack Bruce.
Black Jack Bruce
This story was told to me by an ancient member of my family. I cannot vouch for its exact truth, and I am not certain how John Bruce, known to everyone as Black Jack, was related to me precisely.
But my informant had no obvious reason to invent it.
It apparently happened sometime late in the nineteenth century in a colliery south of the Tyne, where workings extended beneath the North Sea. Coal mining was the family occupation: my grandfather and his father before him, spent his whole working life down the pits.
Black Jack was famous for his racing whippets and his tall black stovepipe hat, like Abraham Lincoln's. He was also passionately interested in politics. I eventually found myself in the Cabinet Room at Number 10 Downing Street, opposite Margaret Thatcher. Evidently the family enthusiasm for political argument had survived a century. Not good news. One point to the geneticists.
Black Jack was notoriously disputatious. It was said he could start a violent argument, all by himself, in an otherwise empty room. That’s not good either. Another point for them.
One morning, a young newcomer named Jim joined his mining crew, having recently arrived from the Cumberland coalfields. The men descended in the cage and set to work with picks and shovels in the hot, cramped galleries. The low ceilings were no great hardship for the Bruces, who have always been small. Any Bruce over six feet immediately prompts enquiries about the milkman.
By lunchtime Black Jack had discovered that the new man shared his enthusiasm for politics but not his opinions. Black Jack, we may suppose, was no admirer of mine owners or capitalists; the newcomer supported capitalism enthusiastically.
The men opened their snap tins, the metal boxes containing their lunches, and the argument resumed. The others, having endured Black Jack's opinions for years, groaned and retired to another gallery to eat in peace.
When the chargehand called them back to work, they returned to find Black Jack and the young man where they had left them. There was, however, a slight difference. Before lunch the young man had been in one piece. Now he was in two, which is not the correct number for a human being.
Most of him lay against a pit prop.
His head was several feet away.
The chargehand raised an inquiring eyebrow.
Black Jack shrugged. "Well, he contradicted me."
Apparently Black Jack had settled the argument with his shovel. The blade, worn thin against coal and stone, had become almost razor-sharp. He had placed it across the young man's throat and put his foot on it, exactly as one might do when digging potatoes.
The Chargehand's Solution
The chargehand foresaw eleven men in the dock, possibly facing the gallows, unless he acted quickly. He ordered them to take a brass check out of his pocket, carry the remains to a gallery abandoned and sealed the previous year, bury them thoroughly, then close it up.
But twelve men had gone down the pit and only eleven could return. Each had been issued a brass check, part of the system for accounting for miners underground in the event of disaster. The chargehand collected all the checks, and added Jim's. Halfway up in the cage, he instructed two miners to start a furious quarrel, leading to a general fistfight.
When the doors opened, they were to burst out still fighting, while he handed in all twelve checks amid the confusion.
First however, every man solemnly swore never to tell anyone: not his wife, mistress, sweetheart, family or priest.
The plan worked. The cage arrived amid shouting and swearing; the miners tumbled out fighting, the attendants recoiled, and the chargehand handed over twelve checks.
He then visited the young man's landlady. "Jim won't be coming back. An urgent telegram arrived at the pit. His grandmother's dying and he's gone home. There's an inheritance coming, so he probably won't return. Give me his Gladstone bag and I'll send his belongings to Workington."
"But he's paid a month's rent in advance. Will he want it back?"
"No, no. He understands. It's hardly your fault."
"You mean I can let the room again?" "Certainly."
Her spirits improved considerably.
"And if any letters arrive from his family, give them to me. I'll see he gets them."
The miners took the Gladstone bag out in a small boat, ostensibly to fish. Beyond Marsden Rock, with the shore reduced to a distant line, they filled it with stones and dropped it into the North Sea.
The chargehand was a canny man, in both senses of the word.
For a while, the oath held. But secrets have a habit of coming out, particularly after a few drinks. Someone drank too much, someone dropped a hint, and eventually everyone knew not to argue with Black Jack Bruce.
Especially if he happened to be carrying a shovel.
Christmas Day, 1969
I was seventeen, and the family was preparing to go to Mass when my father asked me to stay behind and look after my grandfather, Billy Bruce, who visited every Christmas.
Billy had been a coal miner all his life and was reputed to be the worst-tempered man in the north of England, a title for which competition was formidable.
He dressed in a suit and waistcoat, with a gold watch and chain, and polished black boots. I never saw him without a tie.
My instructions were to prepare his usual breakfast: an orange, sliced Hovis brown bread, a pat of butter and proper leaf tea. The bread was not to be buttered; he would do that himself. He had eaten this breakfast for some seventy years.
My father was equally particular. At a picnic once, my mother apologised that the milk for his coffee wasn't hot.
He stared at her. "What are we, savages?"
"And then?" I asked.
"Talk to him. He's an old man with a lot of wisdom. You might even learn something."
Granda descended, immaculate as ever, sat down and said, "Good morning."
Nothing more. He was not a conversationalist.
My parents came from Hebburn and Jarrow, but I grew up in Lower Sunbury-on-Thames, a prosperous village of Georgian houses and wealthy inhabitants.
A few northeastern habits survived however: we said "Granda" instead of Grandad; my father occasionally said "aye" instead of yes; and he loved pease pudding, an unappetising substance to southern eyes.
I struggled for a subject.
Finally, I asked, "Granda, have you any advice for me?"
He fixed me with the penetrating blue-eyed stare apparently possessed by every male Bruce. Fortunately, I was immune, having inherited the same equipment.
After a long pause, he said, "Yes."
"Well, what is it?"
There was another long pause.
"When you're fighting, get your man down as quickly as possible. And make absolutely sure he's on his back."
Having recovered from the surprise of his suddenly introducing the topic of physical violence, I asked, "Why is that important?"
"Two reasons. It's harder for him to get up lying on his back than from his front. And his throat is exposed."
"I see" (although I didn't).
"But why is that important?"
"When you've got him on his back, you just stamp on his throat until he stops moving."
A long silence followed.
"Thanks, Granda. I'll remember that."
Another point to the geneticists, I'm afraid.
Nature or Nurture?
I was taken aback because all this talk of violence was alien to my upbringing. We were a respectable, middle-class family. Grown men settling arguments by physical violence seemed inconceivable. I had been an extremely violent little boy myself, but that's another story. Yet another point to the geneticists.
The score was becoming uncomfortable. An ancestor who apparently decapitated a man simply for contradicting him. A grandfather who offered a seventeen-year-old advice on how to kill a man by stamping on his throat. And a descendant who made a career out of political argument.
So, I remain a fervent supporter of the environment theory. Under the circumstances, I trust you will understand why.
P.S. A few months later, I wanted to go on a solo trip, but my father refused to increase my allowance. Without another ten pounds, the trip was impossible. Furious at the injustice, I marshalled my arguments.
I was a quick-tempered, argumentative young man, and my father was equally argumentative, and (as anybody who has read his Wikipedia page knows), even more quick-tempered.
Yet another point to the geneticists.
Determined to return with a tenner in my pocket, I marched into the vegetable garden of our old Georgian house. My father was working with his back to me.
As I approached, I suddenly realised, to my horror, that he was using a shovel. To dig potatoes.
I stopped.
I paused.
I turned around, and went back into the house.