During the 1988 U.S. vice presidential debate, after a young Dan Quayle compared his record to that of John F. Kennedy, Democratic veteran Lloyd Bentsen paused and delivered one of the most crushing put downs in modern politics: "Senator, I served with Jack Kennedy. I knew Jack Kennedy. Jack Kennedy was a friend of mine. Senator, you're no Jack Kennedy."
Well, let me turn that around. I served with Margaret Thatcher. I knew Margaret Thatcher. Margaret Thatcher was my boss. And I've got a funny feeling that Kemi Badenoch might just be Margaret Thatcher (2.0).
Why? Because Thatcher never won elections by triangulating, splitting the difference, or making cynical backroom deals. She won by standing on clear, unmistakable conservative principles—combining firm national resolve with sound money—and making voters believe she meant every word, mainly because she did mean every word.
Right now, Kemi Badenoch has the same opportunity. She doesn't need to imitate Nigel Farage, and she certainly doesn't need a pact with him. She can win by offering the one thing Reform UK cannot replicate: authentic, disciplined, governing conservatism. If you listen to the pundits in Westminster, the Conservatives face an impossible dilemma.
On one flank, Reform UK is bleeding away traditional working-class and socially conservative voters across the Midlands, the North, and Essex.
On the other, the Liberal Democrats are holding onto dozens of formerly safe Tory seats across the southern "Blue Wall."
The conventional wisdom says Badenoch has to choose. Move right to crush Reform, and you terrify moderate suburban voters in Surrey and Oxfordshire. Move to the centre to win back the Blue Wall, and Nigel Farage eats your lunch.
So, what about an electoral pact with Reform? Forget it. Not because electoral pacts can never work under First Past the Post—they can, and Farage's Brexit Party demonstrated as much in 2019 when it stood down in Conservative-held constituencies. But that was a particular election, fought over the particular issue of Brexit. It is no blueprint for rebuilding a great national political party. A pact today might save a few seats in the short term, but at what cost? Standing down Conservative candidates would weaken local party organisations, alienate moderate voters and concede that the Conservative Party can no longer win elections under its own banner. In southern constituencies, an accommodation with Farage could be a gift to the Liberal Democrats.
And if Badenoch succeeds in establishing a commanding lead over Reform (which is more and more likely, she certainly has the 'Big Mo'), why on earth would she need a pact in the first place? So, if a pact is a dead end, how does Kemi Badenoch actually get back to Downing Street?
She doesn't need to pick one wing of her old coalition and abandon the other. She needs to reunite them.
The electoral evidence suggests that this is far from impossible. Studies of the 2024 election indicate that between two-thirds and four-fifths of Reform voters had backed the Conservatives in 2019. A substantial number of Liberal Democrat voters had done so too. These are not two entirely separate political tribes. They are, to a considerable extent, fragments of the same Conservative coalition that delivered Boris Johnson his landslide majority.
And there is more encouraging evidence. YouGov research published in July 2026 found that 73% of former Conservative voters who had defected to Reform would consider returning, as would 58% of those who had defected to Labour, the Liberal Democrats or the Greens. That is an extraordinary opportunity. The voters haven't necessarily abandoned conservatism. They have abandoned the Conservative Party. There is a difference.
Most of those Blue Wall switchers haven't suddenly become socialists. Many left because they thought the Conservatives had lost their competence, their discipline and their grip on basic public services. Others simply wanted to punish a government that had exhausted their patience. Neither group is necessarily lost forever.
Meanwhile, the things that Reform advocates which are completely unacceptable to any Conservative—like nationalising industries or undermining NATO—are already off the table.
The real battleground comes down to a handful of core issues where a leader can satisfy Reform voters without driving moderate southern voters into the arms of the Lib Dems—simply by standing on genuine conservative principles.
Take Net Zero. Kemi Badenoch has already pledged to repeal the 2008 Climate Change Act and scrap the 2050 Net Zero target. She cannot—and should not—backtrack on that. For many Reform voters, ending green levies and the ban on sales of new petrol and diesel cars is non-negotiable.
Yet for suburban Lib Dem voters, climate and the environment really matter. The way out isn't a U-turn; it's a smart pivot. Frame the policy around cheaper, cleaner, homegrown energy—backing nuclear power, market-led clean technology and putting serious, ring-fenced money into cleaning up local rivers and protecting the countryside. Let capitalism loose on the problem.
There is nothing unconservative about protecting the natural environment. Quite the reverse. Conservatives should be conservationists, as Mrs T was. What they should reject is the idea that environmental protection requires an ever-expanding apparatus of state mandates, subsidies and prohibitions. You can ditch the expensive bureaucracy without abandoning the countryside, the rivers or the air we breathe. That won't satisfy every committed Net Zero enthusiast, but it gives environmentally concerned former Conservatives a perfectly respectable reason to come home.
The same goes for EU trade relations, immigration and the ECHR. Badenoch has committed herself to leaving the European Convention on Human Rights. That will please many Reform voters, but it need not frighten moderate Conservatives if she explains calmly and soberly why restoring parliamentary sovereignty is compatible with protecting fundamental liberties. The argument should not be about Strasbourg jurisprudence. It should be about who makes Britain's laws and who is accountable for them.
Back in the late Eighties I ran the UK Government’s campaign to create awareness of the opportunities and threats involved in the coming Single Market. The reason why the campaign had such a massive budget (about £75 million in today’s money) is that Mrs T was the Single Market’s biggest fan. OK, no going back to the status quo ante Brexit, but it doesn’t mean that we should be trade enemies.
The King of the North can’t advocate closer relations with the EU without being suspected of double dealing and a hidden agenda. But Kemi can. She is in exactly the same position that Kissinger outlined for Nixon in 1972 i.e. who could suspect that a rapprochement led by the old Red baiter could be duplicitous? What both groups ought to be able to agree on is competence and fairness: an end to chaos in the Channel, a firm parliamentary cap on legal immigration, and a welfare system that does not offer newly arrived migrants an immediate claim on the British taxpayer. These are policies that can be defended without shouting, without scapegoating and without pretending that every immigrant is a problem.
Britain has always benefited from immigration. That does not mean it should have unlimited immigration, or that the electorate should have no say in its scale.
Finally, to bring the Blue Wall home, Badenoch has to banish the ghost of 2022. Moderate homeowners want sound money. They want tax cuts that are properly costed, economic stability that keeps borrowing costs down, a protected State Pension, shorter NHS waiting lists and a GP they can actually see. None of this requires abandoning Conservative economics. It requires practising them.
There is no contradiction between reducing the burden of taxation and improving public services, provided the government is prepared to confront the extraordinary growth in welfare spending, eliminate waste and make difficult choices about priorities. Of course, the figures must add up. That is precisely the point. After the Truss debacle, the Conservatives cannot afford another experiment in wishful arithmetic. The party needs to demonstrate, in pounds and pence, how welfare reform, economic growth and spending restraint can finance its commitments. Promising everything to everybody is what Labour does. Conservatives should know better. Put it all together, and you don't need backroom deals with Nigel Farage or populist imitation. You need three clear, disciplined promises that every Conservative can look the country in the eye and deliver:
Of course, no political programme can guarantee an election victory. The Conservatives are starting from a dreadful position, with Reform competing for their traditional supporters and the Liberal Democrats entrenched in former Tory territory. But the evidence suggests that much of the old Conservative electorate remains recoverable. The challenge is to give those voters a convincing reason to return. Voters don't want a copy of Reform UK, and they don't want a watered-down version of Labour. Give them the real thing—the Thatcherite blend of conviction and competence—and the path back to Downing Street opens up.
So, Margaret, sorry—I meant Kemi, are you listening?
*The cartoon comes from an article in Marketing Week that announced and analysed my appointment in 1989 to the position of Conservative Party Director of Communications, effectively becoming Margaret Thatcher’s party spin doctor. I was especially pleased by a comment from my erstwhile mentor, Winston Fletcher CBE: “he is somebody who wins his client’s respect because he is thorough, conscientious and as objective as can be.” I’ll take that.