20 Nov
20Nov


My first memory of France is from childhood: pitching tents (which resembled a small medieval army besieging a large city) in the grounds of a monastery near the sea in Brittany†. 

On Sunday morning, washed and brushed, we set off for the tiny, ancient parish church serving a village of farmers and peasants.

On the way, I asked my mother how we could possibly understand the Mass when it would all be in French.

"No," she explained patiently, "that's the whole point of the word Catholic. Catholic means universal. Wherever you go in the world, the Mass is exactly the same. The priest says the same words, does the same things, and it's always in Latin—the universal language."

Satisfied, we went inside—and to my astonishment, I couldn't understand a single word. As it turned out, a French priest speaking Latin with a thick Breton accent was completely incomprehensible to a small English boy.

This had dire consequences. The moment Mass ended, I complained vociferously that the Catholic Church wasn't universal at all, since I hadn't understood a word. That morning began a lifelong habit of complaining about hierarchies, governments and authorities of all kinds for misinforming me—a habit that continues to this day.

So, when I returned to live permanently in France, I was curious to discover what had happened to the Catholic Church.

Walk through almost any French village, and the physical shell of that older world remains: the medieval church anchors the square, the public calendar still observes Ascension Day and All Saints' Day, and generations of villagers have their names preserved in parish baptismal registers.

But before going any further, let's establish what we mean by Catholic. I don't mean someone who was baptised as a baby, has a Catholic grandmother, enjoys Christmas Mass or admires the architecture of Chartres Cathedral. That's cultural inheritance, not religious belief. For the purposes of this article, a Catholic is someone who believes in the teachings of the Catholic Church and endeavours to follow them in everyday life. That doesn't mean never sinning. The Church would have very few members left if that were the test. It means accepting the faith and trying to live by it. So when I ask whether France is still Catholic, I'm not asking how many French people have a baptismal certificate. I'm asking how many actually believe in Catholicism and practise it. Well, let's see.

1. Catholic by Certificate

The first surprise is that France remains overwhelmingly Catholic—on paper. According to a major IFOP survey in 2025, 76% of French adults were baptised Catholic. But fewer than half still describe themselves as Catholic, and among young adults the proportion is lower still. Baptism, of course, is a peculiar measure of religious commitment. Most Catholics were baptised before they were old enough to object, and the Church regards baptism as permanent. You can stop believing, become an atheist, denounce the Pope, and spend the rest of your life avoiding churches. You remain baptised. 

Meanwhile, infant baptism has declined dramatically. Catholicism is no longer being passed automatically from one generation to the next. There is, however, a fascinating exception. At Easter 2026, more than 13,000 adults were baptised into the French Catholic Church, the highest number in recent decades. Young adults were particularly prominent. Something is attracting them to the Church. But it is nowhere near enough to reverse the long decline. France is moving from a country where Catholicism was inherited almost automatically to one where it is increasingly a conscious choice. And fewer people are choosing it.

2. The Sunday Test

In Catholic teaching, attending Sunday Mass is a religious obligation, not an optional extra. Yet according to IFOP's 2025 survey, only 5% of French adults attend Mass every Sunday or more often. And fewer than half of French people now say they believe in God. So France has millions of baptised Catholics who don't go to Mass, millions who no longer call themselves Catholic, and millions who don't believe in God at all. Of course, a person can be a sincere Catholic and occasionally miss Mass. But when church attendance has become an unusual activity in a supposedly Catholic country, something fundamental has changed. For an institution whose central business is saving souls, this must be discouraging.

3. Catholic, but Not That Catholic

Perhaps the most revealing test is whether those who still call themselves Catholic actually believe what their Church teaches. Take abortion. The Catholic Church teaches that human life must be protected from conception. France, meanwhile, became the first country to explicitly guarantee freedom of access to abortion in its Constitution in 2024, with overwhelming parliamentary and public support. 

Or take same-sex marriage. The Church distinguishes between homosexual orientation, which it does not regard as sinful, and homosexual acts, which it condemns. It reserves sacramental marriage for a man and a woman. French Catholics have made up their own minds. Pew Research Center found that 74% supported legal same-sex marriage in a survey conducted in 2017. Now, supporting the legal right of others to do something is not necessarily the same as approving of it morally. But the gulf between Catholic teaching and French attitudes extends well beyond marriage. The same disagreements appear over contraception, divorce and assisted dying. 

And here we encounter the central contradiction. Catholicism is not an à la carte religion. Its teachings on faith and morals are determined by the Church, not by opinion polls or the personal preferences of individual Catholics. You are perfectly free to disagree with the Pope. You are free to reject Catholic teaching altogether. But you cannot redefine Catholicism to accommodate your objections. Millions of French people retain the Catholic label while rejecting teachings of the Catholic Church. They may be Catholic by baptism or cultural inheritance. But by the definition established at the outset, that is not enough. You cannot claim Catholicism without Catholic belief.

4. Parliament and the Press: The Convenient Catholic

France's political institutions offer another illustration. The National Assembly does not keep a register of deputies' religious beliefs. Nor does laïcité, France's constitutional principle of state secularism, require politicians to abandon their personal faith. It requires the Republic to remain neutral towards religion. Nevertheless, French legislation increasingly reflects secular public opinion rather than Catholic moral teaching. The constitutional amendment on abortion is the clearest example; the parliamentary debate over assisted dying provides another. But there is something particularly curious about the political use of Catholicism in France. Some politicians and commentators become passionate defenders of France's Christian heritage whenever immigration, Islam or national identity enters the conversation. 

Suddenly, Catholicism becomes the very foundation of French civilisation. Church towers must be defended. Christmas cribs must be preserved. France's Christian roots must never be forgotten. All very well. But defending a church tower is not the same as going to Mass, and proclaiming the Christian origins of France is not the same as accepting Christian doctrine. Catholicism becomes a badge of national identity, conveniently detached from the obligations of being Catholic. 

At the other end of the political spectrum, secular commentators sometimes seem equally perplexed by the growing number of young people seeking baptism. Neither side has quite grasped the distinction. Catholicism as cultural inheritance, Catholicism as political identity and Catholicism as religious faith are three different things. Only the last answers the question we're asking.

5. The Secular Republic Owns the Churches

Now we come to my favourite French absurdity. Walk past that little village church in Brittany—or almost any historic parish church in France—and you encounter an extraordinary arrangement. The Catholic Church usually doesn't own the building. The secular Republic does.

The explanation lies in the Revolution, the Napoleonic settlement and the 1905 Law on the Separation of Churches and State. Most historic parish churches belong to their local communes, while many major cathedrals belong to the national State. The Church retains free use of these buildings for worship. So the mayor owns the church, but the priest controls its religious use. The financial arrangement is equally peculiar. Although the Republic is constitutionally secular and generally prohibited from subsidising religious worship, public authorities can spend taxpayers' money maintaining and restoring the religious buildings they own. They are not automatically obliged to repair every church roof. Nevertheless, ownership brings responsibilities, and across rural France cash-strapped communes face the expensive problem of preserving magnificent medieval buildings whose congregations have dwindled to a handful of worshippers. The secular mayor must decide how much public money to devote to the church, even when almost nobody attends it. 

And then there is Alsace-Moselle, where the 1905 separation law does not apply in the usual way, and the State still pays the salaries of Catholic priests and clergy of certain other recognised religions. Yes, you read that correctly. In one part of secular France, the government still pays Catholic priests. Explaining why (like the Schleswig-Holstein Question) would require another much longer article, several maps and possibly a stiff drink. The larger irony is irresistible. The French Republic, which has spent more than a century insisting upon the separation of Church and State, remains one of the principal custodians of Catholic Europe's architectural inheritance. It may no longer believe in the Church, but it still has to worry about the roof.

The Verdict

So, is France still Catholic? If Catholicism means medieval churches, monasteries, public holidays, baptismal certificates and a thousand years of cultural inheritance, then emphatically yes. 

But that is not the definition we established at the beginning. If Catholicism means believing in the teachings of the Catholic Church and endeavouring to live by them, the answer is no. There are, of course, committed Catholics in France, and the recent surge in young converts shows that the faith is far from dead. But a country does not remain Catholic simply because its ancestors were. France has preserved the architecture, the holidays, the ceremonies and much of the vocabulary of Catholicism. What it has largely abandoned is the religion itself. The churches remain. I still hear the bells of the local church on the hill across the little valley ring out the Angelus. The Republic still pays to repair the stonework. It's just the congregation that's missing.


† A Brief Detour in Rouen

That monastery in Brittany was too far to reach in a single day, so, to our great excitement, we were booked overnight into a hotel in Rouen. 

Because there were ten of us, we needed a suite of interconnecting rooms, and the entire first floor of an old half-timbered building on the market square was put at our disposal. After we had explored a little, our mother called us over to stand at the open windows. When we were suitably quiet and concentrating, she pointed down towards the square.

"Now children, if you look at that spot in the middle, that's where St Joan of Arc was burnt at the stake."

We all stared down, goggle-eyed, in respectful silence.

Which was broken by my father's voice behind us:

"Yes, the English have always liked a nice open fire."


Commentaires
* L'e-mail ne sera pas publié sur le site web.