There’s a lot of interest just now in the Bloomsbury set, provoked by a new exhibition at the Tate (the proper one in Pimlico, not the ridiculous tourist attraction on the Surrey bank) of the work of Duncan Grant & Vanessa Bell.
That news (and terrible reviews) reminded me of a conversation I had in France in 1971, when I was a very callow nineteen-year-old.
Back in the early 70s hardly anybody took a gap year between school and university, but I did, as I was thoroughly sick of a schooling that had so badly interrupted my education.
So, having celebrated my A levels results in a manner so outrageous it attracted the attention of the village plod, attended the Isle of Wight festival (Joni!), opened the letter from Warwick confirming my place for 1971, I moved out of the family home, a rambling mid-Georgian house by the river in Lower Sunbury which my Italian brother-in-law always referred to as ‘The Palazzo’, and got myself a place in Fulham.
After working for six months or so at Cadby Hall, the headquarters of J Lyons – a factory that made pastries, cakes, ice cream and pies (where Margaret Thatcher had also once worked as a food scientist) – my father suggested I go and work for an old chum of his from the war.
The man was called ‘Bish’ Elstob, because as a baby he slept with his hands folded like a bishop. He had served in the Royal Marines, and when his ship was sunk in the North Sea, only he and one other man (from a raft full of forty men) survived to step off onto a Dutch beach.
He had gone to live in the Lot in south-west France because, after the Navy, he had been a wine buyer, and had come to know and like the region, then not very well known to the English, when buying wine in Cahors.
When his marriage went terribly wrong, he bought a Pickford’s pantechnicon and loaded it with the meagre possessions he was left with after the bitterly contested divorce, plus some monstrously Victorian furniture purchased cheaply from an emporium in Peckham; a brand new wife, Meg, and his new father-in-law, Alfred.
He then bought a ruined farmhouse for almost nothing just outside a pretty little place called Montcuq. It sounds lovely to English ears, but to the French it sounds like “mon cul” – “my arse” – and its inhabitants had been the butt of the joke for many centuries.
My job was to help him restore old buildings, as the area was just being discovered by super-rich property developers from England, who made dubious fortunes in The Smoke, spent it buying up huge castles, and were in want of someone reliable to make small-scale repairs.
There were other local colonies too: Dutch artists, American writers and one in particular that fascinated me, White Russians. I’ll never forget walking into the farmhouse’s enormous blackened kitchen one day to find a group of elderly women shelling peas and gossiping in Russian. When I asked who they were, Bish replied airily, “Oh, they’re all Baltic Princesses who fled after the Revolution.”
One day the primitive bathroom in the farmhouse gave out completely, so we went into Montcuq and visited the town’s château, which was owned by an English couple who had recently bought it from Sir Roland Penrose, Picasso’s friend and biographer, and his wife, the famous American photographer, Lee Miller.
I was asked to use a guest bathroom, which turned out to be a room about the size of a tennis court with only five objects in it, all huddled into one corner: a massive Victorian cast-iron bath; a rickety wooden towel rail; one of those ghastly thin French towels, more like a tea towel than something you might dry yourself with; an extremely dangerous copper geyser to heat the water; and a Blue Period Picasso.
After my bath I heard the unmistakable sound of British expats having a drink on a terrace: a mixture of soda siphons, tinkling glasses, brays of laughter and occasional exclamations of extreme indignation.
I went out, still pretty damp, and was quickly offered my then favourite, a gin and lime, and a box of Gitanes papier maïs – the yellow-papered cigarettes that agricultural labourers traditionally smoked, which always went out halfway through, rather like a pipe, and then stayed jammed in the corner of the smoker’s mouth for the rest of the day.
We were soon joined by a man in his late 70s with snowy white hair, who lived in a grace and favour cottage in the castle’s grounds. As I was the only person he didn’t know, he looked at our hostess enquiringly, and I was introduced to ‘Bunny’. By this time, I had developed the technique of listening carefully until the conversation revealed who the newcomer was.
“Seen much of Angelica recently?”
“No,” said Bunny, “and I don’t expect to.”
Who was Angelica, and why was she out of favour? No clue was provided.
“How about Duncan?”
“No, I haven’t seen him for a while either.”
“I suppose he misses Vanessa awfully.”
Suddenly the conversation was starting to make some sense. Bunny must in fact be Duncan Grant’s lover, David Garnett, the son of Constance Garnett, the famous translator of the Russian novelists, and Angelica must be his wife – the daughter of Duncan Grant (Bunny’s erstwhile lover) and Vanessa Bell (Virginia Woolf's sister).
Now I could see my way a little clearer. I had wandered into Bloomsbury-sur-Lot, where, as Dorothy Parker put it, people “lived in squares, painted in circles and loved in triangles” – and what a triangle this was.
That evening at dinner, Bunny told me the story behind it. When Duncan Grant and Vanessa Bell had their baby, Angelica, Vanessa was still married to Clive Bell, who didn’t kick up any fuss but simply pretended the baby was his own. Bunny (who was then 26) came across to see the new arrival. He looked into the pram and said, “Oh, what a remarkably beautiful child. Wouldn’t it be fun if one day I married her?” This didn’t seem to go down very well with Vanessa, so he changed the subject. But the extraordinary thing is that he did marry the baby in the pram. That was the Angelica he had been asked about on the terrace of the château, when we were having our after-bath drinks.
A few weeks later a party was given in Bunny’s honour at the farmhouse, the bathroom having been mended by a succession of French plumbers, each one with the regulation papier maïs cigarette drooping over his bottom lip.
I found myself sitting on the sofa with Bunny drinking the Poire Williams that Bish acquired from an illegal travelling still which was run by an Occitan-speaking man with permanent garlic breath who lived in a part of the country so far from civilisation that their only amusements were incest and eating blinded ortolan soaked in Armagnac with a towel over your head.
I had been reading The Plumed Serpent by D. H. Lawrence, and as I knew Bunny was famous for saying “Oh yes, I knew him well” whenever a name came up, I asked whether he had ever met Lawrence.
“Oh yes,” said Bunny, “I knew him well.”
“Oh really?” said I, getting excited.
“Yes,” said Bunny. “I often used to go down to Southampton every weekend and help him with his motorboats.”
“Really?” said I, now somewhat puzzled. “I never knew he was interested in engines.”
“Oh yes,” said Bunny, “he was fascinated by all things mechanical, and he’d been given the job of developing fast motor launches that were going to be used by the RAF for sea rescue.”
“Did you also meet Frieda?” I asked.
“Who?” said Bunny, puzzled.
Putting that down to the inevitable deafness of everybody over the age of 40, I asked again, a little louder this time, saying “his wife, Frieda”.
Bunny looked at me and said, “I think you’ve got that wrong, jeune homme. Lawrence was never married.”
That was when the light bulb went on. We had been talking at cross purposes: he had been talking about Lawrence of Arabia, and I had been talking about DH Lawrence, the working-class novelist. Then something occurred to me.
“Did you know both Lawrences? Did you know DH as well?”
“Bert? Oh yes, I knew him well.”
So now I decided to test exactly who else he had met, other than the obvious candidates in Bloomsbury – Forster, Strachey, the Woolfs, Keynes, various Bells, Frys, Mortimers and Partridges. “Bunny, who’s the most famous person you’ve ever met?”
“Oh dear,” he said, rubbing a patch of stubble he’d forgotten to shave off that morning. “I suppose Tolstoy.”
Then emerged the story of how his mother, the translator, had taken him as a child to Russia to meet the great man, although he remembered little from the encounter.
We chatted about Galsworthy and Conrad for a while, then, as I was thinking at the time of writing a play about H. G. Wells, he was next on my list.
“Oh yes, I knew him well. We used to play that funny game Bertie (Wells, not Lawrence, do try and keep up) invented in his barn.”
“What game?” I asked.
“Well, it was a bit like real tennis. ‘Barn Ball’ Bertie called it. You got points by hitting the ball against various beams, because it was an old wooden barn with a rather complicated roof structure. That’s what got T. E. into trouble.”
So apparently, we were back to Lawrence of Arabia. “How so, Bunny?”
“Well, one day Lawrence was staying with the Wellses because Bertie was helping him with the ‘Seven Pillars’ book, and they were playing a game of bicycle polo in the same barn, for which sawdust was specially put down to stop broken bones.”
“So he was injured?”
“No, no, he was AWOL – absent without leave. He was so caught up in the game he forgot to go back to the tank depot where he was stationed, and decided to stay the night as it was too late to go back on his motorcycle. He was immediately arrested on his return the next day.”
“What happened to him, Bunny?”
“Well, he was interviewed by the Depot Battalion CO, who said, ‘Well, Private Shaw**, have you anything to say in your defence?’ and Lawrence replied, ‘Yes, Sir, I was playing bicycle polo with His Grace the Archbishop of Canterbury.’
The commander then gave him an extra day of jankers for insolence.
So imagine the Colonel's surprise one week later to receive a letter from Lambeth Palace, from the Archbishop of Canterbury, asking for leniency in the case of T. E. Lawrence on the grounds that the Archbishop was partially at fault for encouraging him to continue to play the game.”
Bunny asked what I was reading.
“Henry Miller’s Sexus,” I said, “which I’d found secreted under some shirts left behind by a previous guest.”
“Interested in pornography, are you?”
“About the same as the next chap, I suppose.”
“I only ask,” Bunny said, “because I’m thinking of writing a pornographic novel.”
“Why?”
“My publisher seems to think it will make money, and I’m a bit short at the moment.”
Unfortunately, Bunny died before Andrew Lloyd Webber had a massive hit adapting his novel Aspects of Love, which made Bunny's heirs two million dollars. And he never wrote the porno book.
And there’s also a very sad cautionary tale postscript about Bish.
One day I was driving my Harley-Davidson from Clermont-Ferrand back to the Gallery and decided to drop in on Bish and his wife Meg, whom I hadn’t seen since a Colditz reunion my father took me to years before.
The farmhouse seemed deserted, so I went out to the newly built swimming pool and found two very polite Brits, who explained that they thought Meg was having a nap and that Bish was still in bed as he was feeling poorly.
I went back to the farmhouse, went in and found her asleep on the sofa. Sensing my presence, she woke up and I said, “Meg, it’s Brendan, Dominic’s son.”
“Oh yes,” she said, “Dominic,” in a slightly dazed way.
“Is Bish around?” I asked.
“Yes, he’d love to see you. He’s still in bed, the doctors say he must spend most of the day there. I want to get him out for lunch, though, so it’s a good excuse.”
We sat chatting at a table on the sunny vine covered terrace. Through a large set of French doors, I could see Bish slowly getting himself ready to see me, and eventually he came out.
“I’d know you anywhere,” he said. “You’re the spitting image of your father at the same age.”
I pretended never to have heard this before, although it was probably the thousandth time someone had said it to me. We chatted for a while, but I could see that his heart condition was making him very tired, so I said I must be going, as I had 100 kilometres or so to drive.
He insisted on coming to see me off. I had parked the customised turquoise and cream Harley on the castine drive, and he laughed when he saw it.
“Yes, I expected you to be driving something unusual.”
A couple of years later, I got a message from Meg’s kindly niece, who lived in Scotland, but often came to look after them. The local doctor had come in for his weekly visit to Bish, and Meg had complained to him that she was also feeling unwell.
“Well, why don’t I examine you after I’ve talked to your husband?” he said, and asked Meg to lie on the sofa. He took out his stethoscope and put it to her chest, but was surprised to find that it wasn’t working. He glanced at her and realised she had died, just as he was putting the stethoscope to her.
The moral of this story quickly emerged. All their financial planning had been made on the assumption that Bish, with his very frail health, would die first. Meg, usually so robust, would have inherited, although under French law some of it would have to go to the son he had left behind in the 60s, the boy he had never seen since. Then in turn, the faithful niece would inherit a charming house that had been her second home for fifty years. Instead, Bish was put into one of those local state-run homes for the elderly, and I went to visit him.
The home was new and very well furnished, with an en suite bathroom, but it was terribly quiet, and he seemed both very lonely and pleased to see me.
“Come on in, Dominic,” he said, “tell me all the news.” I didn’t disabuse him. What would be the point? As I left, I said, “I’ll leave a card with the nurse at reception. If you want me, just get her to call me on that number.”
“Right-o, Dom,” he said. “Take care.”
That was the last time I ever saw him. When he died a few months later, the son flew in, went to the estate agents, told them to sell the house and transfer the money to his UK account, went to the funeral, went straight back to the airport and was never seen again.
As they say, if you want to make God laugh, tell him your plans.
PS Bunny did write a book about all those people he knew well, it's called 'Great Friends: Portraits of Seventeen Writers', published in 1979. No one reads it now, nor even his bestsellers like Lady into Fox.
In the era when heterosexuality is the love that dare not speak its name, Bunny Garnett is now only (slightly) famous simply because he was once Duncan Grant’s lover.
*The portrait of Bunny by Duncan Grant (above) was painted in 1915, when he was 23.
** Not ‘Trooper’ – that didn’t come in until much later for those tankers. I remembered that ‘Trooper’ is comme il faut for cavalry regiments when a Life Guard was blocking the passageway underneath the arch between Horse Guards and Whitehall. The government driver (I was with the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster, who is entitled to an Ivory Pass) refused to approach the soldier, who had his back to us and clearly hadn’t heard us approach. I got out of the car and, in my best pretend Sandhurst parade-ground voice, shouted, “Trooper! Stand aside!” He stiffened to attention instinctively and took two steps to his left, clearing the way for the car. If I’d said ‘Private’, he would have known I was a miserable civilian fraud, and had me put on a charge.
The Chancellor and his Ivory Pass turned out to be a trump card in all sorts of situations. I once parted the waves like Moses at the State Opening of Parliament. It was impossible to cross over the road to the Abbey side, so I went up to the constable on duty at the zebra crossing and, pretending to be a Close Protection Officer, said, “Please stop the traffic to let the Chancellor through.” The copper immediately stepped through the street liners and held up his gloved hand to stop the entirely imaginary traffic to let us cross. David 'Gang of Four' Owen quickly attached himself to the party, complaining that he’d been kept waiting for twenty minutes, after repeated refusals by the ‘more-than-my-job’s-worth’ bobby to let a mere former Foreign Secretary through.
Chutzpah, takes you a long way in life. And you don't even have to be Jewish.