I was asked recently at a dinner party whether I had any children. "Good God Almighty, no," I blurted out. "That certainly wouldn't have been a very good idea." My hostess looked at me as if I had just confessed to a minor felony of a sexual nature, and swiftly changed the subject.
Yet the question stuck. What on earth would I do if I had to educate a child today?
I certainly wouldn't send them to Katharine Birbalsingh's Michaela Community School in Wembley, where pupils march between lessons in dead silence and eat lunch by the rulebook. Not for me and mine, and yet I completely understand why she built it, and why it is so successful. From my personal observation, modern parenting has largely collapsed into indulgent negotiation. Far too many parents (excepting those who send their children to the Wembley school, or any decent private school) treat basic manners and self-control as an assault on their child's self-expression, dumping the job of civilising (and potty training) their offspring onto teachers. I wouldn't choose Birbalsingh's methods for my children because they wouldn’t need them, but she is dead right about the disease—and dead right to take an axe to the establishment lie that "diversity is our strength".
When politicians, HR departments, museum directors, race grifters, BBC executives and vice-chancellors chant "diversity is our strength", they are pulling a fast one. By diversity, they mean surface demographics: race, sex and ethnicity. When it comes to diversity of thought—the freedom to dissent, challenge orthodoxies and offend the polite consensus—they want none of it.
A boardroom or university department can look like a Benetton ad and still think with one compliant (or cowed) brain. Worse, identity politics has turned victimhood into Britain's premier currency. Citizens are sorted into a rigid caste system of oppressors and oppressed based on skin colour or sex, and handed privileges or penance accordingly. A privately educated millionaire can ludicrously claim victim status because of their background, while a struggling white (white) van man with a St George’s Cross tattoo on his chest is lectured on his "privilege". Dare to question this racket and you are smeared as bigoted, or at best lacking empathy.
Real victims of discrimination whatever the source (which in Britain is mainly class) deserve the full protection of the law. Nobody deserves inherited guilt, and nobody should be born into a lifetime subscription to victimhood.
Besides, the whole premise is bogus. In modern Britain, social class—not race—is the real predictor of success. Look at the numbers. In the 2021 Census, 52% of people identifying as Indian in England and Wales held a higher-level qualification, compared with 34% of the population as a whole. Office for National Statistics figures for 2022 showed Indian workers out-earning White British employees on median hourly pay. Meanwhile, the Institute for Fiscal Studies has shown persistent struggles among other minority groups. If "white privilege" were running Britain, those numbers would be impossible. Family culture, expectations, school quality and economic class matter infinitely more than skin colour. Importing American racial obsessions to explain British society isn't just lazy; it is actively blinding us to what actually holds people back.
In her book Diversity Is Not Our Strength, Birbalsingh compares a nation to a football team. A team does not win trophies because its players tick different demographic boxes. It wins because they wear the same shirt, obey the same rules and play for the same badge.
Britain should be intensely relaxed about ethnic and cultural variety, after all we are not French -who think banning the hijab is a road to racial harmony.
We are British, so wear what you like, when you like. In my universe, everyone is equal, except (obvs) Arsenal supporters. If everyone else signs up to one social contract: equality before the law, free speech and personal responsibility, we’ll be fine.
Instead, we are stuck between a ‘progressive’ left obsessed with group grievance and a ‘reactionary’ right peddling its own tribal identity politics. Between the two, the centre-right has mostly cowered in the corner, terrified of being called names. It is time for the Tories to grow a pair. A future Conservative government (something that is looking increasingly likely) should keep the Equality Act's core ban on discrimination intact, and then take a legislative blowtorch to the bureaucracy/media ‘diversity’ complex: Here are my
Seven Laws to Kill the Grievance Industry
Passing laws to dismantle identity politics is only half the job. You cannot beat something with nothing, and anti-woke rhetoric alone will not win elections, despite what that great public intellectual of our time, Nigel the Unready, believes.
To command the centre ground, the centre-right needs a bold, positive strategy built around genuine equality of opportunity—one that tackles class disadvantage head-on. A poor kid growing up in a gutted coastal town or an inner-city estate faces steep odds that a rich child in leafy Surrey never will—regardless of either child's skin colour.
Pretending race is Britain's main fault line is a massive con that lets the chattering classes ignore millions of working-class families of every background. While the far left obsesses over racial quotas and the hard right flirts with ethnic nationalism, the centre-right should be the ruthless champion of the individual on the make. Fix failing schools, reward hard work and self-discipline, strip away barriers to business and open up business and the professions to talent from every postcode. Help people rise because they are poor but capable—never because they belong to a favoured demographic bloc.
Since the fall of Mrs T, the centre-right has let the left write the political dictionary, nodding along to talk of "privilege" and "inclusion" while institutions and corporations turned into conformity factories. Enough.
A great football team needs one shirt, one set of rules and one objective. Plus, King Harry.
Its success comes from different talents and clashing ideas pulling in the same direction.
One country, one law, real opportunity for every working-class kid to exploit their talents, and the absolute right to speak our minds. Not the monstrous regiment of HR’s slogan ‘different shirt, same minds’.
But St Katherine’s ‘Same shirt. Different minds’.