17 Nov
17Nov

 I live in France permanently now, and I don’t get back to London very often. In fact, my visits have become increasingly rare—usually dictated by the practical need for a personal MOT (mostly getting my teeth and eyes checked, plus whatever my rampant hypochondria is generating that week) and getting my hair cut by the peerless Mr Refat at Trumpers (a slight misnomer, as he trims half of the House of Lords). For what it’s worth, I haven’t noticed any great changes on those trips, and I wouldn’t particularly care if I did. 

Still, over coffee the other morning, I caught a headline suggesting that London was heading towards a non-white majority sometime in the 2030s. It made me pause. Not because the prospect particularly troubled me, but because it reminded me how spectacularly unreliable our impressions of a city can be, even when we think we know it rather well. 

I am a Londoner born and bred, but my own geographical horizons have always been absurdly narrow. To me, there are only two tribes worth mentioning in London—and by “London”, I mean everything north of the river up to Hampstead Heath. And they are not divided by ethnicity. My tribe worships at the shrine of The Golden Cockerel, and it is the Tribe of Good. The Tribe of Evil worships the gun, and they are beyond all redemption. (If you are on the side of righteousness, feel free to chant along with me now: COYS!) 

Because I see the capital only in brief snapshots these days, I probably experience much of it rather like a tourist. Which got me thinking about how an actual first-time visitor—blissfully unaware of North London’s sacred tribal boundaries—might experience the place. 

Take, for instance, Arthur and Beverly Miller of Oatmeal, Nebraska, who had never set foot outside the United States until their golden wedding anniversary finally prompted a bucket-list trip across the Atlantic.

 Before boarding their flight in Omaha, Arthur had skimmed a few alarming headlines online—pieces warning that white people were on their way to becoming a minority in London, and commentary suggesting that the traditional character of the city had already been swept away by demographic change. 

So, as the Millers’ cab rolled in from Heathrow towards their hotel near Victoria Station, they expected to arrive in a metropolis that was already predominantly non-white.

 Five days later, over afternoon tea in Kensington, Beverly looked around the room and whispered to Arthur: “I don’t know what those newspapers were talking about. Everyone here looks just like us.” 

The Millers weren’t necessarily unobservant. They had simply stumbled into one of the most fascinating illusions of modern urban life: when you visit a global city like London, what you see is not what you get. In the Millers’ minds, they were seeing the real London. 

They went from Buckingham Palace to the V&A, took in a matinee in the West End, and strolled through Green Park. On the pavements, in the pubs and in the theatre stalls, they encountered plenty of people who looked much like themselves. 

To a couple from the American Midwest (where their home county in Nebraska would be 95% white), the newspaper warnings suddenly seemed rather overdone. And yet the census tells a more complicated story. According to the 2021 Census, 53.8% of Greater London's residents identified as White and 46.2% as belonging to other ethnic groups. In other words, London remained a white-majority city, although not by a particularly large margin. 

But Greater London is not the London most tourists visit. Arthur and Beverly spent almost their entire holiday in a handful of central districts, surrounded by a constantly changing population of residents, office workers, commuters, shoppers and fellow tourists. 

They were not observing a representative sample of nine million Londoners. They were observing whoever happened to be standing in front of Buckingham Palace that morning. Even within Westminster, where 55.2% of residents identified as White in the 2021 Census, the people on the streets are not necessarily the people who live there. The daytime population is transformed by commuters and visitors from elsewhere in London, the rest of Britain and abroad. 

And there is another complication. A white face tells you remarkably little about the person behind it. A French banker, a Polish accountant, an Italian barista and an American tourist may look indistinguishable to Arthur and Beverly. None comes with a nationality stamped on the forehead. 

In short, the Millers were trying to draw conclusions about the permanent population of a vast metropolis from the appearance of the people they happened to encounter during a five-day holiday. Not a particularly scientific method. 

Nor, of course, is London remotely uniform. In Newham, approximately 69% of residents identified with non-white ethnic groups in the 2021 Census. In Brent, the proportion was around 65%. Both boroughs are part of the same London as Kensington and Westminster, yet they can present a very different picture of the city's population. The Millers would never have discovered this from their itinerary. They had no particular reason to visit Newham or Brent, any more than a visitor to Paris is likely to abandon the Louvre and the Champs-Élysées for an afternoon studying the residential streets of Seine-Saint-Denis. 

They did, however, take the Underground. And there, particularly during the rush hour, they began to encounter a much broader cross-section of Londoners. On the Jubilee Line between Green Park and Westminster, Arthur found himself in a carriage that looked rather different from the dining room where they had taken afternoon tea. “Good heavens,” he might have whispered to Beverly. “Perhaps those newspapers were right after all.” But that conclusion would have been just as unreliable as the first. A Tube carriage is no more representative of London than a Kensington tearoom. It is simply another small, temporary collection of people, assembled by geography, time of day and chance. 

There was, however, another way in which the Millers were misreading the city, and it was rather more interesting. Throughout their holiday, they encountered people from a variety of ethnic backgrounds working in the businesses and services that made their visit possible. There was the hotel concierge, the chambermaid, the restaurant staff and the Underground employees who helped them navigate a transport system that Beverly regarded as unnecessarily complicated. Without consciously thinking about it, the Millers began to construct a picture of London's ethnic minorities as the people who performed the city's everyday service jobs. 

They were perfectly courteous to everyone, naturally. Arthur was not the sort of man who failed to tip a helpful concierge. But in their minds, these workers occupied a particular place in the social hierarchy: the people who looked after the visitors, rather than the people who owned, managed or directed the institutions around them. And here their impressions became particularly misleading. London's ethnic minorities are not simply a workforce of hotel employees, cleaners, waiters and transport workers. They include surgeons, barristers, financiers, senior executives, entrepreneurs, academics and professionals occupying some of the most demanding and highly rewarded positions in the capital. Indeed, the occupational achievements of some ethnic minority communities make nonsense of the assumption that London's racial diversity can be understood as a simple division between a prosperous white population and a disadvantaged non-white one. 

Consider the British-Indian surgeon at Guy's Hospital, the Chinese quantitative analyst in Canary Wharf or the successful entrepreneur living in Harrow. None is particularly likely to feature in Arthur and Beverly's account of their London holiday. Not because such people are invisible, but because their professional lives take place in hospitals, offices, laboratories and businesses that tourists rarely enter. And their homes may be in prosperous residential districts that no sightseeing bus has ever considered worth visiting. The Millers could spend an entire week admiring the city's great institutions without meeting many of the people who actually run them. 

There is a further psychological complication. We human beings are remarkably bad at estimating the proportions of different groups within a population. We notice what is unusual, memorable or conspicuous, and then unconsciously exaggerate its statistical importance. 

Ipsos demonstrated this rather neatly in its 2018 Perils of Perception research. Asked to estimate the proportion of Muslims in Britain, respondents produced an average figure of 17%, compared with the approximately 4% figure used in the survey. Asked about immigrants, they estimated 24%, against an actual figure of around 13% at the time. These were national figures, not London statistics, but the psychological lesson applies just as well to the capital.

 People do not walk around with a census in their heads. They remember faces, encounters and impressions. A crowded Tube carriage, a busy street market or a particularly striking television report can leave a much stronger impression than any official population table. 

Take London's Black Caribbean population. In the 2021 Census, people identifying specifically as Black Caribbean accounted for approximately 3.9% of the capital's residents. Yet somebody whose experience of London consisted largely of particular neighbourhoods, cultural events or transport routes could easily come away with the impression that the proportion was much greater. 

Equally, Arthur and Beverly could spend several days in central London and conclude that white residents remained overwhelmingly predominant. Both impressions might be entirely sincere. Neither would necessarily bear much relationship to the arithmetic. And that, surely, is the point. The argument about London's changing ethnic composition is too often conducted as though everyone can establish the truth simply by looking around them. One commentator walks through a predominantly non-white neighbourhood and announces that London has become unrecognisable. Another strolls through Kensington Gardens and wonders what all the fuss is about. Both believe the evidence of their own eyes. Both may be completely wrong. 

The census, of course, does not suffer from this particular weakness. It counts residents rather than impressions, and its figures are not altered by whether someone happens to be standing outside Harrods or waiting for a bus in Newham. 

But even the census cannot tell us what London will look like in ten or twenty years. Projections about future ethnic majorities depend on assumptions about migration, births, deaths and other demographic changes. They are forecasts, not facts, however confidently a newspaper headline may present them. When Arthur and Beverly finally boarded their flight back to Omaha—much as I return across the Channel after passing my own annual MOT—they carried home a curiously contradictory impression. From their hotel window and the stalls of the West End theatre, London had seemed like an extension of old Europe: stately, familiar and reassuringly similar to the city they had imagined. From the Underground, the hotel reception desk and the crowds on the pavements, they had glimpsed something rather more complicated. 

But they had missed an even larger part of the picture: the ethnic diversity of London's professional, commercial and intellectual life, much of which operates well beyond the tourist's field of vision. London is a city of roughly nine million people, spread across thirty-two boroughs and the City of London, with enormous differences in population, prosperity, housing and social composition. Nobody can understand such a place from a few days of sightseeing. Nor, for that matter, from a handful of newspaper headlines. The Millers went home believing they had seen London. What they had actually seen was a tiny and thoroughly unrepresentative selection of it. And that is why, when it comes to London's changing population, what you see is very often not what you get.

Commentaires
* L'e-mail ne sera pas publié sur le site web.