18 Nov
18Nov

Look at this photo. Taken by a ChatGPT photographer, it is an expanded version of the famous photograph of the "Nine Kings," which was taken on May 20, 1910, in the White Drawing Room at Windsor Castle. While the original portrait captured nine European monarchs who had gathered in person for the funeral of Britain’s King Edward VII—the beloved "Uncle of Europe"—this composite imagines what the room would have looked like if all twenty reigning monarchs of Europe had assembled that day. 

At the dawn of the 20th century, almost the entire continent was ruled by crowned heads linked together by blood and marriage. Looking at this group portrait, it appears to be a display of unshakable imperial permanence. In reality, it was the calm before a century-long storm. 

Here is who is in the room— what happened to them, and their thrones: 

  • 1. King Alfonso XIII of Spain – Forced to flee Spain in 1931 upon the proclamation of the Second Spanish Republic, he died in exile in Rome in 1941. Spain descended into civil war and decades of dictatorship before sensibly restoring its monarchy in 1975.
  • 2. Emperor Franz Joseph I of Austria-Hungary – Died in 1916 during World War I, two years before his centuries-old empire collapsed into fragments in 1918.
  • 3. Queen Wilhelmina of the Netherlands – Europe’s only reigning queen at the time; she was forced into exile in London when Germany invaded in 1940, returning after the war.
  • 4. King George V of England – Reigned peacefully until his death in 1936, guiding his country through World War I with its crown and constitution intact.
  • 5. Tsar Nicholas II of Russia – Overthrown in the Russian Revolution of 1917 and murdered alongside his entire family by the Bolsheviks in 1918, ushering in decades of a murderous Soviet dictatorship.
  • 6. Kaiser Wilhelm II of Germany – After leading Germany into defeat in World War I, he abdicated in 1918 and spent the rest of his life in exile in the Netherlands as Germany slid toward Nazism via socialism.
  • 7. King Frederick VIII of Denmark – Died suddenly in 1912. Denmark kept its monarchy, though it was invaded and occupied by Germany during World War II.
  • 8. King Victor Emmanuel III of Italy – Stood by as Benito Mussolini turned Italy into a fascist dictatorship, a decision that led Italians to vote out the monarchy entirely in 1946.
  • 9. Sultan Mehmed V of the Ottoman Empire – Died just before the end of World War I, after which his empire collapsed and the sultanate was abolished in 1922.
  • 10. King Carol I of Romania – Died in 1914. Romania later endured royal and fascist dictatorships before Soviet-backed communists abolished its monarchy in 1947.
  • 11. King Haakon VII of Norway – Forced into exile in London when Germany invaded Norway in 1940, returning to his throne in 1945.
  • 12. Tsar Ferdinand I of Bulgaria – Forced to abdicate in 1918 following Bulgaria’s defeat in World War I, he died in exile in Germany as Bulgaria eventually fell behind the Iron Curtain.
  • 13. King Manuel II of Portugal – Deposed in a republican revolution just months later in October 1910, he lived in exile in England while Portugal endured decades of dictatorship.
  • 14. King George I of Greece – Assassinated by an anarchist in 1913. Greece spent the next sixty years cycling through wars, coups, and military dictatorships before abolishing its crown in 1973.
  • 15. King Albert I of Belgium – Became a national hero leading his troops in World War I before dying in a climbing accident in 1934. Belgium was invaded and occupied by Germany in both World Wars.
  • 16. King Gustaf V of Sweden – Reigned until 1950. Through neutrality, Sweden avoided invasion in both World Wars and kept its crown.
  • 17. King Peter I of Serbia – Overrun in World War I, his kingdom merged into Yugoslavia, where communists abolished the monarchy in 1945.
  • 18. Prince Nicholas I of Montenegro – Elevated to King later in 1910, he was forced into exile in France when Montenegro was absorbed into Yugoslavia in 1918.
  • 19. Grand Duke William IV of Luxembourg – Died in 1912. Luxembourg was invaded and occupied by Germany in both World Wars, though its royal family survived.
  • 20. Prince Johann II of Liechtenstein – Reigned until 1929 over a tiny principality that remained neutral and kept its monarchy intact.

Within just four years of May 1910, World War I tore this extended royal family apart, setting the stage for decades of revolution, fascism, and communist rule across the continent. When you trace the fate of these nations from 1910 to the present day, a remarkable historical pattern emerges. Most of these monarchies were abolished—and in almost every case, the fall of the crown did not usher in a peaceful democratic republic, but rather civil war, authoritarian dictators, or Soviet colonisation -sometimes all three. 

Even amongst those countries that kept their royal families, nearly all were invaded and occupied during the World Wars. In fact, out of all the major powers in that room, only one survived continuously up to the present day as a stable, peaceful, and prosperous democracy that was never invaded and never suffered under a dictatorship: the throne of England. 

The reason England survived untouched while its neighbours fell comes down to one simple truth: it was able to defend itself successfully. Under the unbroken line of King George V, it possessed the strength, resolve, and geographic advantage to fight off aggression without its soil ever being conquered, or its parliament ever falling to a dictator. 

Of course, history shows there were alternative, cheaper but a lot less honourable approaches to survival—neutrality and trade. Sweden kept its crown and avoided invasion by declaring neutrality and pretending that Hitler's gangsters were acceptable neighbours you could happily sell iron ore and raw materials to while the rest of Europe burned. 

Dev’s Ireland, on the other hand, chose trade and in 1939 signed an agreement with Herr Hitler to export agricultural goods like beef, butter, and eggs—a cozy arrangement that was only cut short when the British naval blockade physically prevented Irish ships from reaching German ports once the war began. 

After Hitler shot himself in the bunker, De Valera visited the German Ambassador to offer his condolences. The enemy of your  enemy is apparently your friend -although not for thousands of Irish soldiers who left their homes to fight fascism, only to be called shoneen, and cold-shouldered in the streets of Dublin.

England chose to stand and fight instead, and more than a century after this photo, its uninterrupted peace and freedom remain the ultimate reward for that resilience. Peace and democracy are never self-sustaining; they only survive when a nation has the capability and the will to protect them. 

So the next time someone says to you that we're spending too much on defence, show them this photo.

Commentaires
* L'e-mail ne sera pas publié sur le site web.